Declaring dividends by reference to interim accounts: a potential trap for public companies

Published on 1st Apr 2015

A number of ratification circulars have been published by listed companies in recent years, seeking to put right dividends which (because the necessary distributable profits did, in fact, exist) could have been lawfully made, but which were unlawful due to the failure to file “interim accounts” demonstrating those distributable profits – and thereby justifying the dividend – at Companies House.

Whilst relatively easy to fix and certainly not the worst thing that could happen to a listed company, having to convene a general meeting and ask shareholders to release the directors (and shareholders themselves) from potential personal liability to repay the dividend is time-consuming, potentially costly and may have adverse reputational consequences.

The issue: justifying dividends by reference to relevant accounts

Under sections 836 and 838 Companies Act 2006, a company can only pay a dividend out of distributable profits as shown by relevant accounts. These will be the last annual accounts circulated to members, or, if those accounts do not show sufficient distributable profits to justify the dividend, “interim accounts” showing adequate reserves.

Share buy backs

The same rules requiring justification by reference to relevant accounts apply to determining the adequacy of distributable profits to fund a buy back of a company’s shares. Accordingly it may be necessary to file interim accounts in support of a buy back programme. If the rules are not followed, the buy back will be void. And, generally speaking, unpicking an unlawful buy back is considerably more difficult than putting right an unlawful dividend.

The requirements for interim accounts for private companies are quite relaxed and usually a recent set of management accounts will be used. But, for public companies, additional requirements apply under section 838 Companies Act 2006 (see box below). These include filing the interim accounts at Companies House, and it is this filing requirement which has wrong-footed a number of listed companies.
The rules apply equally to interim dividends (dividends declared and paid by the board, usually during the course of the financial year) and final dividends (dividends recommended by the board and approved by an ordinary resolution of the shareholders – usually at the company’s AGM). Final dividends are therefore usually declared by reference to the annual accounts circulated to members prior to the company’s AGM. Whilst interim accounts are most often used in connection with interim dividends, they are sometimes also necessary for final dividends in order to capture a post-year end event which has improved the company’s distributable profit position.

Interim accounts requirements for public companies

  • Must enable a reasonable judgment to be made of the profits, losses, assets, liabilities, required provisions, and share capital and reserves of the company
  • Must be “properly prepared” (i.e. prepared in the same manner as the company’s individual accounts (subject to a carve out for any matters not material for determining whether the proposed dividend is lawful)) 
  • The balance sheet comprised in the accounts must be signed on behalf of the board
  • Must be delivered to Companies House 

Section 838, Companies Act 2006

The consequences of an unlawful dividend 

The procedural rules on dividends under the Companies Act are strict, and, if the dividend is justified by reference to interim accounts which have not been filed prior to the dividend being paid, the dividend will be unlawful; this is the case even if there is significant headroom in the distributable profit position. For final dividends declared by reference to interim accounts, companies will want to ensure that interim accounts are filed before the dividend is approved by shareholders (the dividend becoming a debt owing by the company once approved). 

The legal consequences of an unlawful dividend are, in theory at least, draconian. Shareholders can be pursued for repayment of the dividend, and directors can be personally liable to repay the dividend, having acted in breach of their duties. Putting it right involves the release of both shareholders and directors from the potential liability to repay the unlawful distribution (the release of the directors constituting, for companies subject to the Listing Rules, a related party transaction and requiring approval by the independent shareholders and a fair and reasonable opinion from the company’s sponsor). Ensuring that the procedural requirements of the Companies Act are followed when making both final and interim dividends will avoid these headaches.

Share
Interested in hearing more from Osborne Clarke?

* This article is current as of the date of its publication and does not necessarily reflect the present state of the law or relevant regulation.

Connect with one of our experts

Interested in hearing more from Osborne Clarke?